The best Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes range from treehouse and cabins in nature to luxury lake houses and vacation rentals with pools and hot tubs. If you’re dreaming of a peaceful lakefront getaway, just wait until you see these Finger Lakes vacation rentals on Airbnb and VRBO.
Located within a five-hour drive from cities like NYC, Boston, and Philadelphia, the Finger Lakes is one of the coolest vacation destinations in New York. It’s comprised of 11 finger-shaped lakes, each offering some amazing wineries, nature spots, and top-notch vacation rentals. These stays provide a safer and more authentic experience than traditional hotels, which makes it especially appealing in the age of COVID.
If you’re in need of some R&R this spring, summer or fall, this region of Upstate New York has got you covered. This article covers the best lodging in the Finger Lakes, which includes Airbnbs, VRBOs, and cabins for rent in the Finger Lakes. Here, we’ve ranked the best Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes, which include places like Ithaca, Watkins Glen, Seneca Lake, Geneva, Naples, Cayuga Lake, Skaneateles Lake, Keuka Lake, Canandaigua, and more. Now, let’s pour a glass of wine and explore the Finger Lakes!
First time using Airbnb? Here’s my special code to get $65 off your first booking!
Click here to save $65 with Airbnb!
The Coolest Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes: Top Vacation Rentals in 2021
Here are the best Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes by category, taking into account different amenities, trip types, and budgets. The next sections will cover each listing, as well as other Airbnb vacation rentals, in more detail.
Top Airbnb in the Finger Lakes: Castle Point Paradise in the Finger Lakes
Best Luxury Rental Finger Lakes: Dramatic Lakefront Chalet in Ithaca
Top Romantic Airbnb in the Finger Lakes: Naples House with Hot Tub
Best Finger Lakes Airbnb for Large Groups: Elegant Estate Tucked in Nature
Best Cheap Airbnb Finger Lakes: Hunt Hollow Cottage and Spa
Coolest Treehouse Airbnb in the Finger Lakes: Leap Frog Treehouse
Best Cabin Rental Finger Lakes: Cozy, Quiet Cabin on Seneca Lake
Top Airbnb Finger Lakes with Pool: Copper Ridge Hillside Retreat
Best Winter Airbnb Finger Lakes: Cozy Winter Getaway in Canandaigua
Best Lake House Rental Finger Lakes: A-Frame Cabin on the Lake
Most Unique Airbnb in the Finger Lakes: Luxury Houseboat on Seneca Lake
19 Best Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes
If cabins, treehouses, romantic lake houses, and luxury vacations rentals overlooking vineyards in the Finger Lakes all sound good to you, get excited! Below are some of the most unique stays in the Finger Lakes.
Note: Some of the properties below are featured on both Airbnb and VRBO. For each listing, I’ve only included the link to the website with the cheapest rates.
1. Keuka Outlet Cabin Rental in the Finger Lakes
Location: Penn Yan, New York
Rates from: $289 per night
Accommodates: 6 guests
This Finger Lakes cabin rental is the perfect place to spend a summer vacation. It’s set on 40 acres of beautiful woodsy property with plenty of privacy and seclusion.
From this vacation rental in the Finger Lakes, you’ll only be a short distance from Keuka Lake and the many shops and restaurants around it. However, once you step foot inside this romantic log cabin home for rent in the Finger Lakes, it will be hard to leave!
2. Castle Point Paradise: Gorgeous Cabin with Lake Views
Location: Himrod, New York
Rates from: $378 per night
Accommodates: 8 guests
If you’re looking for the quintessential Finger Lakes experience, look no further. This gorgeous cabin overlooking Seneca Lake is the best-value Airbnb you’ll find in the Finger Lakes region. It offers sweeping lake views, log cabin vibes, a spacious deck with a hot tub, and even private balconies in the rooms. I can’t imagine a better home base for exploring the Seneca Lake Wine Trail, and the Finger Lakes in general.
Soak in the hot tub and catch the sunrise and sunset from this amazing Airbnb in the Finger Lakes. You won’t have to stay anywhere else!
3. Dramatic Lakefront Chalet in Ithaca: The best luxury Airbnb rental in the Finger Lakes
Location: Ithaca, New York
Rates from: $2,500 per night
Accommodates: 12 guests
This is one of the most beautiful buildings, let alone Airbnbs, in the Finger Lakes region of New York. It proudly stands watch over Lake Cayuga, one of the most beautiful lakes in upstate New York.
Comprised of 5,000 sq. ft. of living space, this luxurious chalet is decked out with everything you’ll need for a memorable stay, including 2 docks, a custom hot tub, a home theater/projector, three fireplaces, and more. The attention to detail is staggering, with beautiful wooden furnishings and fixtures that resemble the chalets of the Swiss Alps.
With incredible lakefront and all sorts of amazing amenities, this chalet definitely deserves to be mentioned among the best Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes.
4. Naples Vacation Rental in the Finger Lakes with Hot Tub and Deck
Location: Naples, New York
Rates from: $295 per night
Accommodates: 6 guests
Looking to stay at one of the most romantic Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes? This vacation rental in Naples takes the cake.
It’s set on 6 private acres between Canandaigua and Keuka Lakes, overlooking a valley. Enjoy the cozy hot tub and fire pit, or go down the street to taste some amazing wines and craft beers which these region of New York is known for. This is definitely one of the most romantic settings imaginable, so bring your significant other and let go of all of life’s worries.
5. Cozy Finger Lakes Cabins for Rent on Seneca Lake
Location: Lodi, New York
Rates from: $158 per night
Accommodates: 2 guests
Looking to stay at one of the best-value cabin rentals in the Finger Lakes? This cozy lakefront home is calling your name!
Located on the east side of Seneca Lake, this private cabin rental is just a few miles from many top wineries, breweries, and waterfalls. Enjoy stunning sunsets and days spent kayaking and paddle boarding on the lake. With so much charm and personality, it’s no wonder this is among the best Finger Lakes vacation rentals!
6. Wine Trail Estate Surrounded by Nature – Among the Coolest Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes
Location: Rock Stream, New York
Rates from: $1,090 per night
Accommodates: 16 guests
Experience the magic of the Finger Lakes from this grand estate in the countryside. It’s set on 5 acres of peaceful land, equipped with 8 bedrooms and 8 baths, making it one of the best Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes for large groups.
Take advantage of the Seneca Lake Wine Trail that’s nearby. Or spend the days relaxing in the outdoor hot tub and taking in the gorgeous nature views.
Curl up beside one of the 3 fireplaces at night, and you’ll see why this historic estate is among the coolest Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes region of NY!
7. Tiny House Cabin Rental in the Finger Lakes
Location: Penn Yan, New York
Rates from: $125 per night
Accommodates: 2 guests
This tiny house vacation rental in the Finger Lakes is ideal for couples looking for a romantic retreat in nature. It’s set in a 8×20 ft. shipping container on 10 acres filled with Sycamore and Black Walnut trees.
Go hiking and bike riding around the property. Hit the local wineries and breweries. And after a long day of activities, retreat to this beautiful Finger Lakes cabin rental in the middle of nature. It won’t be long until you see why it’s among the coolest vacation homes in the Finger Lakes!
8. Hunt Hollow Hideaway and Spa – One of the best cheap Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes
Location: Honeoye, New York
Rates from: $150 per night
Accommodates: 6 guests
Located in the heart of NY wine country, this unique Airbnb in the Finger Lakes is the perfect home base for relaxation. It’s set on 9 acres of beautiful woodsy property with gardens, a creek, and hiking trails.
Gaze up at a sky full of stars from the hot tub, and you’ll see why this is one of the best Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes.
9. Leap Frog Tree House – Best Airbnb Treehouse in the Finger Lakes
Location: Hemlock, New York
Rates from: $250 per night
Accommodates: 3 guests
Feed your imagination from this unique Airbnb treehouse in the Finger Lakes.
It’s set on 100 acres of pristine land, home to a variety of wildlife and two ponds. There are several trails on the property that you can explore, and two canoes and a kayak you may use during your stay.
Fun fact: this treehouse is solar powered! Can you imagine a more romantic Airbnb treehouse in the Finger Lakes? I think not!
10. Eco Barn Home with Amazing Views – Top Finger Lakes Vacation Rentals for Couples
Location: Burdett, New York
Rates from: $396 per night
Accommodates: 2 guests
For a romantic stay in Upstate New York, look no further than this Finger Lakes vacation rental with sensation views.
This newly constructed barn home was built mostly with organic, reused materials. It offers glass doors in every room, bringing the outdoors to you. Enjoy the privacy and seclusion from the pavilion, fire pit, and pond. There’s also an organic garden, berry bushes and fruit trees. You won’t be far from many local wineries, hiking trails, and waterfalls. However, after stepping foot inside this mesmerizing Finger Lakes rental, it will be hard to get up and leave!
11. Cozy Finger Lakes Cabin Rental on Seneca Lake
Location: Penn Yann, New York
Rates from: $297 per night
Accommodates: 6 guests
This magical cabin on Seneca Lake is easily one of the top vacation rentals in the region. It boasts stunning views of the lake, and the interior log cabin design is equally spectacular.
Take a refreshing swim in the lake or make some s’mores in the fire pit. The fall foliage around the property is also stunning.
Visit any time of year, and you’ll appreciate the cozy cabin experience. What more could you want in one of the coolest cabins in the Finger Lakes?
12. Hillside Retreat in the Finger Lakes Region with a Pool
Location: Beaver Dams, New York
Rates from: $759 per night
Accommodates: 8 guests
Discover the best that the Finger Lakes has to offer from this large vacation rental in the middle of nature.
This home lies near the Finger Lake Wine Trail and Watkins Glen, but you won’t want to leave the property after you see its salt water hot tub and pool! There’s also a pool table, foosball, ping pong, cornhole, and frisbee golf. Plenty of fun for the whole family!
Stay at this 70-acre property in the Finger Lakes region, and you’ll never want to vacation anywhere else.
13. One of the Best Houses to Rent in Finger Lakes NY with Hot Tub
Location: Geneva, New York
Rates from: $350 per night
Accommodates: 4 guests
This gorgeous house to rent in the Finger Lakes will leave you speechless. It’s located on Seneca Lake with incredible views as far as the eye can see.
Be sure to spend plenty of time rejuvenating in the hot tub, playing ping pong, and Pac Man. Enjoy a cocktail on the Adirondack chairs with views of the lake. You’ll only be a stone’s throw away from the Seneca Lake Wine Trail and many other top attractions in the region. With so much to see and do throughout the property, it’s easy to see why this is among the top Finger Lakes vacation rentals!
14. Chickadee Cabin – Among the Best Cabins for Rent in Finger Lakes
Location: Hemlock, New York
Rates from: $147 per night
Accommodates: 4 guests
For nature lovers, it doesn’t get any better than this cabin for rent in the Finger Lakes. It’s situated in the woods and has all the rustic amenities you’ll need for a memorable stay.
Make use of the backyard area with a fire pit and hammock, as well as a small pond with a dock and pedal boat. I can’t imagine a better place to recharge your batteries than at this beautiful Finger Lakes cabin rental!
15. The Little House – Cozy Winter Getaway
Location: Canandaigua, New York
Rates from: $215 per night
Accommodates: 4 guests
Looking for a cozy Airbnb in the Finger Lakes to visit in the winter? This one is among the best.
It’s set on a 14 acre property with beautiful views and all the amenities you’ll need for a comfortable stay. If you’re looking to go skiing, you’ll be happy to know that the Bristol Mountain Ski Resort is just a few minutes away.
In the warmer months, take advantage of the swimming pool, hiking trails, campfire, and grill on the property. You’ll also be close to many great farmer’s markets, wineries, and craft breweries. There’s truly something for everyone here, so it’s no wonder this is among the best vacation rentals in the Finger Lakes.
16. The Ultimate Lake House in the Finger Lakes
Location: Auburn, New York
Rates from: $475 per night
Accommodates: 10 guests
Experience the Finger Lakes in style at this luxury lake house in the Finger Lakes. It’s one of the only A-frame cabins in the region, where you’ll have cozy cabin vibes with all the benefits of being right on the lake.
Wake up every morning with a cup of coffee as the sun rises over the lake. Go canoeing, kayaking, and swimming in the lake. And soak in the hot tub or sauna after a long day in the sun. There’s truly no better Airbnb lake house in the Finger Lakes than this one. The location near Skaneateles and Filmore Glen State Park is perfect, too!
17. Finger Lakes Houseboat Rental on Seneca Lake – The Most Unique Finger Lakes Vacation Rental
Location: Geneva, New York
Rates from: $495 per night
Accommodates: 10 guests
Looking to stay in one of the most unique Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes? You’re looking at it.
Measuring 67 feet long and 15 feet wide, this luxury Finger Lakes houseboat rental is the perfect way to experience Seneca Lake. It’s fully equipped with a deck, a hot tub, gas grill, waterslide, and watersports. Spend the afternoons swimming in the lake or grilling on the deck. You won’t want to experience the Finger lakes any other way!
18. Lakeside Suite – Vacation Home for Rent in the Finger Lakes on VRBO
Location: Ithaca, New York
Rates from: $161 per night
Accommodates: 2 guests
This charming apartment rental on Cayuga Lake is perfect for small groups and couples. It’s just 5 minutes from Downtown Ithaca and the wine trail, but this VRBO rental feels world’s apart from this serene location.
Relax as you take in the epic views and listen to the water and the wind. Enjoy a glass of wine after swimming in the lake and going paddling. Is this one of the top lakefront cabins for rent in the Finger Lakes? 100%!
19. Waneta Lakeside Cottage – Among the Top Finger Lakes Vacation Rentals
Location: Dundee, New York
Rates from: $179 per night
Accommodates: 4 guests
It would be a crime to list the top Finger Lakes houses for rent without mentioning this one in Dundee, NY. This quaint lakeside cottage is nestled on Waneta Lake, one of the best hidden gems in the Finger Lakes Region of New York.
Dine and relax on the covered deck with views of the waterfront. Take advantage of the private beach with 4 kayaks. This is especially a nice place to stay during the peak fall foliage season when wine season is in full swing. If you’re dreaming of the perfect lake house vacation rental in the Finger Lakes, look no further!
Best Places to Stay in the Finger Lakes NY
Still unsure of where to stay in the Finger Lakes? Here are my favorite cities, towns, and nature spots where I recommend staying:
– Top Cities and Towns: Auburn, Canandaigua, Geneva, Hammondsport, Ithaca, Penn Yan, Seneca Falls, Skaneateles
– Best Cabins and Campgrounds: Watkins Glen
– Coolest Lakes: Canandaigua Lake, Cayuga Lake, Keuka Lake, Seneca Lake, Skaneateles Lake
Top Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes NY
Have you stayed in any unique Airbnbs or vacation rentals in the Finger Lakes? Let me know in the comments, as I’m always looking to add to this lineup of the best Finger Lakes Airbnbs!
If you’re looking for more cool destinations in the northeast USA, check out these destinations:
– The Best Airbnbs in New York State
– Unique Airbnbs in New England
– Top Airbnbs in the White Mountains
– Coolest Airbnbs in Massachusetts
– Unique Airbnbs in Rhode Island
– Best Airbnbs in the Berkshires
